Whisky Comparison

Sign up for unlimited free access to all the Pro features while we're in Beta testing.

  Compare Any 2 Spirits
How are we doing? Take the 90 second Survey
Ratings ?
Score:
0.0
Rank: 33.2 pctl
Value: $0.82 / pctl

Subject Whisky

See Most Similar Whiskies
Superior Recipe No. 12 image
George Dickel Superior Recipe No. 12
Our 90-proof Tennessee Whisky. We blend older whiskies to achieve deep, assertive flavors with an incredibly smooth finish. Bold and brazen, this is our Recipe No. 12. Concentrated flavors of rich oak and subtle vanilla lead to a long finish with hints of maple, butter and smoke. A whisky with enormous depth, range and personality- considered by many to be the gold standard of Tennessee Whisky.
 84% Corn • 8% Rye • 8% Malted Barley • High Rye
 Ratings: 
Whisky Advocate: 86.00 pts 
Connosr: 88.00 pts 
Whiskybase: 75.00 pts 
Total Wine: 92.00 pts 
Wine Enthusiast: 90.00 pts 
The Whiskey Jug: 87.00 pts 
Drink Hacker: 85.00 pts 
Part of the  Diageo family of brands.
Tasting Notes
Nose: Aroma of rich oak, charcoal and sweet smokiness .
Palate: Subtle notes of vanilla, with hints of maple syrup, buttered bread and smoke.
Finish: Finish is long and complex, with touches of roasted corn, raisins, and smoke.
Ratings ?
Score:
0.0
Rank: 64.6 pctl
Value: $0.92 / pctl
Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel
 78% Corn • 12% Malted Barley • 10% Rye • High Malted Barley
 Pro Ratings: 
Universal Spirits: 91.00 pts 
Intl Wine & Spirits: 91.00 pts 
Whiskybase: 85.10 pts 
Total Wine: 90.00 pts 
Wine Enthusiast: 93.00 pts 
Flaviar: 88.00 pts 
Drink Hacker: 90.00 pts 
Part of the  Heaven Hill Distilleries family of brands.
Tasting Notes
Nose: Lots of toasted oak with rich caramel.
Palate: Big, rich, and complex. Delightful spice and pepper notes fade to milk chocolate with just a hint of smoke.
Finish: Complexity continues. Nicely warming, with lingering chocolate and baking spices.
How are we doing?

Contact Us

Email us: support@whiskymates.com

Or, tell us what's up:

Logo © 2026 Whisky Mates, Inc.