Whisky Comparison

Sign up for unlimited free access to all the Pro features while we're in Beta testing.

  Compare Any 2 Spirits
How are we doing? Take the 90 second Survey
Ratings ?
Score:
0.0
Rank: 22.0 pctl
Value: $1.25 / pctl

Subject Whisky

See Most Similar Whiskies
Straight Rye Mountain Whiskey image
Tincup Straight Rye Mountain Whiskey
Tincup Straight Rye Mountain Whiskey is a 90-proof, 3-year-aged rye whiskey produced by Tincup Whiskey, inspired by Colorado's mining history. It is a blend of 95% rye and 5% malted barley distilled in Indiana, then cut with Rocky Mountain water. It offers a bold, spicy profile with notes of vanilla and caramel.
 95% Rye • 5% Malted Barley • High Malted Barley
 Ratings: 
Whisky Advocate: 88.00 pts 
Whiskybase: 78.00 pts 
Wine Enthusiast: 93.00 pts 
The Whiskey Jug: 78.00 pts 
Drink Hacker: 85.00 pts 
Part of the  BECLE, S.A.B. DE C.V.  family of brands.
Tasting Notes
Nose: Fresh and inviting aromas of sweet vanilla, caramel, and nutmeg blend with distinct notes of baking spice, dried orchard fruits, and a hint of dusty, woody dill
Palate: A light-to-medium bodied profile features a smooth, sweet entry of custard and brown sugar that transitions into a bold rye spice, notes of orange marmalade, and soft charred oak
Finish: A lingering and slightly warming finish leaves a peppery, yet smooth impression with lingering caramel, tobacco, and silky tannins.
Ratings ?
Score:
0.0
Rank: 50.8 pctl
Value: $0.69 / pctl
Redwood Empire Whiskey Emerald Giant Rye
Redwood Empire Emerald Giant Rye is a highly regarded, budget-friendly craft rye whiskey produced by Redwood Empire Distilling in Sonoma County, California. It is a blend of aged rye (3-5 years) from Indiana (MGP), Kentucky, and their own distillery, known for a 95% rye mash bill, 90 proof, and a sweet, spicy profile that features notes of citrus, cinnamon, and pepper. Reddit r/bourbon.
 95% Rye • 5% Malted Barley • High Malted Barley
 Pro Ratings: 
Whisky Advocate: 87.00 pts 
Whiskybase: 83.00 pts 
Total Wine: 88.00 pts 
Wine Enthusiast: 87.00 pts 
Flaviar: 95.00 pts 
The Whiskey Jug: 83.00 pts 
Drink Hacker: 85.00 pts 
Independently Owned
Tasting Notes
Nose: A vibrant nose of baking spice, citrus zest, and sweet caramel with a hint of dried dill
Palate: Notes of toasted oak and creamy caramel blend into a bold, spicy rye punch, featuring cinnamon and orange peel
Finish: Long and warming with lingering notes of rye spice, sweet oak, and a subtle herbal undertone.
How are we doing?

Contact Us

Email us: support@whiskymates.com

Or, tell us what's up:

Logo © 2026 Whisky Mates, Inc.