Whisky Comparison

Sign up for unlimited free access to all the Pro features while we're in Beta testing.

  Compare Any 2 Spirits
How are we doing? Take the 90 second Survey
Ratings ?
Score:
0.0
Rank: 33.8 pctl
Value: $2.07 / pctl

Subject Whisky

See Most Similar Whiskies
Madeira Cask image
Penderyn Madeira Cask
Penderyn Madeira Cask is a flagship Single Malt Welsh Whisky from Penderyn Distillery, matured in ex-bourbon barrels and finished in Madeira wine casks for a light, fruity, and approachable profile. Bottled at 46% ABV, it is known for notes of toffee, caramel, raisins, and a dry, crisp finish. It is often credited with putting Welsh whisky back on the global map.
 100% Malted Barley
 Ratings: 
Whisky Advocate: 94.00 pts 
Whiskybase: 81.44 pts 
Total Wine: 92.00 pts 
Wine Enthusiast: 87.00 pts 
Flaviar: 74.00 pts 
The Whiskey Jug: 85.00 pts 
Drink Hacker: 85.00 pts 
Independently Owned
Tasting Notes
Nose: Fresh and aromatic with a vibrant mix of creamy toffee, rich sultana raisins, orchard fruits, and a hint of sweet Madeira wine
Palate: Crisp and refined with a soft, oily mouthfeel, delivering flavors of sweet caramel, cinnamon, tropical fruit, and balanced oak
Finish: Medium-long and drying, featuring lingering notes of vanilla, toasted raisins, and a gentle spice.
Ratings ?
Score:
0.0
Rank: 23.6 pctl
Value: $2.33 / pctl
Shieldaig 12 Year Rum Cask
Shieldaig 12 Year Rum Cask Finish is a Speyside Single Malt Scotch whisky aged for 12 years and finished in rum casks, producing a light, sweet, and fruity profile. Often found at Total Wine & More as a budget-friendly offering, it offers notes of creamy sugar, orchard fruits, vanilla, and oak, with a 40-43% ABV.
 100% Malted Barley
 Pro Ratings: 
Whisky Advocate: 85.00 pts 
Whiskybase: 79.00 pts 
Total Wine: 90.00 pts 
Wine Enthusiast: 90.00 pts 
Part of the  Ian Macleod Distillers family of brands.
Tasting Notes
Nose: A light and welcoming aroma of candied orange, brown sugar, and vanilla cream, with hints of tropical banana and fresh cut grass
Palate: Medium-bodied and sweet, featuring notes of sugarcane, spiced oak, citrus zest, and soft toffee that lead to a slightly dry finish
Finish: Medium length and smooth, fading with lingering notes of cream, vanilla, cinnamon, and toasted oak.
How are we doing?

Contact Us

Email us: support@whiskymates.com

Or, tell us what's up:

Logo © 2026 Whisky Mates, Inc.